Jeremy was my student back in about 1987. He was part of an English 10B class, or sophomore basic English. In that level of English, students were not college-bound; they could have mild to serious reading deficiencies; they were often discipline problems; their attendance could range from perfect to chronic absenteeism, and coaches loved it for athletes. Teachers were urged to make each day a complete lesson so that any kid coming in on any day wouldn't feel like he had missed anything. He could pick right up and get to work, completing it in class and turning it in for a grade.
I found quickly that a routine worked well. Mondays were vocabulary days; Tuesdays were reading and answering question days; Wednesdays were grammar days, etc. The students loved knowing ahead of time what to expect, and they thrived. The class that Jeremy was in was a nice group of kids who got along well and liked each other and me. We had a mutual respect.
Jeremy asked me on the first day of class if he could sit in the front row. He explained that his father and he felt it kept him attentive, and I obliged. He was tall, with long legs and a basketball player's body. I often had to navigate those outstretched legs as I wrote on the board at the front of the class and talked. "If those legs get any longer, I'm going to put you by the door and watch you trip people in the hallway," I used to say. He'd grin and blush a little under his freckles.
He was a good-looking kid, mixed race, his skin the colour of coffee with too much milk, brown eyes, an impeccable fade, and the kind of lanky, loose body that was born to be athletic. His smile was wide, winning, yet shy-looking somehow. He was a hard worker who could have a short fuse if he got frustrated.
One day a new student was added to the class. He arrived late, and I could see by his swagger and demeanour that he was going to upset our community, or at least try. Nonetheless, I greeted him warmly, accepted his pass, and assigned him a seat. Immediately, the rest of the class began to react to him, and not very positively, by rolling their eyes and mumbling under their breath.
"Here's what we're doing," I said, handing him a book and a copy of the worksheet. "If you need anything, just let me know."
"Shit, I don't need nothin'. I just got out of Indian River. This is my class now. You--"
Quick as anything, Jeremy was up and out of his seat. "This is Ms. D's class. You're gonna treat her with respect. I don't care about where you were or why you were in prison. If you're in here, it's Ms. D's class, period. You don't like it, you can leave. And there's lots of us can help you."
I'd like to say that I immediately took charge of the situation, but I stood there, open-mouthed and stunned for a moment. The whole class had turned toward the offender, staring him down. Jeremy was still standing. After a moment I grabbed an incident report and started writing and said to the new student, "I think you'd better head down to the office. That's enough for today."
He stood up, remarked that he was just about to leave anyway, and walked out the door. Another student took the incident report to the office, and I never saw that kid again.
In the aftermath Jeremy apologized for standing up and speaking out of turn. "But no way was I gonna let him disrespect you!" Others spoke up indignantly as well. The best thing was that they all wanted to keep our class dynamic as it was.
Jeremy tried out for basketball and made the JV team and went on to play Varsity as well. His dad was a fixture in our school. He was an involved parent, making sure Jeremy was doing well and keeping the grades up, staying out of trouble.
For many kids like Jeremy at our high school, it's tough to get into college. Passing the ACT and/or the SAT is a huge barrier. Then, affording college is another hurdle. Athletic scholarships help, but even then, they're often to small, faraway colleges that take them a long way from their families. That's often an insurmountable obstacle, especially when the colleges aren't very diverse.
I lost track of Jeremy after his senior year. I had my second baby, and life got so busy. The next thing I knew, I was reading his name in the newspaper (June 27,1991), but not for basketball. He was arrested for the death of a man at a gas station. The man had been beaten so brutally that he had died from his injuries; the newspaper said that it was a drug deal gone wrong. He was twenty years old.
Jeremy, I later found out from someone who had been in that English class, had gotten involved with drug dealers. It was the easiest and fastest way to make money. He was twenty years old. He's fifty now, and he's in prison for the rest of his life.
My heart broke when I read that story in the newspaper. How could he? I wondered. What happened to him? What went so terribly wrong?
Sometimes I think that what I did for thirty years of my life didn't make a damn bit of difference. But I realize that I'm a tiny part of a huge environment. Jeremy deserves punishment, of course, but I mourn for him nonetheless.
Wow. That's all I can say
ReplyDeleteAnni--That's how I felt then, and how I still feel now. Jeremy haunts me to this day.
DeleteI second Anni's wow. That story quickly took a turn. It probably seemed just as quick for Jeremy. Shocking and sad.
ReplyDeleteShirley--It felt (and still feels) impossible to me. So out of his character. How could he have ended up even worse than the kid who disrupted our class? I think about him so often.
DeleteSuch a tragedy.
ReplyDeleteEllen--I agree. Jeremy's fall haunts me still. I can't let it go.
DeleteThey each take a tiny piece of your heart with them. I could cry ... watched the grandkid graduate ... virtually ... about an hour ago. She has so much. And so many of these children have so little, and so few ways out.
ReplyDeleteMary--Congratulations to your grand! I know you're very, very proud, and rightly so.
DeleteAs a teacher in a big urban school, I was not foolish enough to think that I could make a huge difference when so many of these kids are up against so much. I tried to make their time in my class a place of consistency and trust, and a place where they could enjoy learning. My heart was broken over and over again, but not to the extent that Jeremy shattered it. I just don't understand, and I know I never will. It's a terrible loss.
I am more than sure that your class was just such a place as you describe, having followed your blog for so much enjoyment. No, it is impossible to understand why some kids make it and some can't. For those of us who do, the fear and anger of those left behind are incomprehensible. You can only hope that for every Jeremy there is another, anonymous, for whom your care and skill helped them open a door. I have to tell myself that. And, in all honesty, it is why I enjoy teaching adults ESL. Simpler dynamic all around.
DeleteOh Nance, I'm so sorry. This is such a heartbreaking story. I suppose there are probably more than a few good kids in situations like Jeremy's that make a wrong turn after high school and end up ruining their lives. So, so sad.
ReplyDeleteMartha--Oh, I'm certain that Jeremy's story has been replayed time and time again. It's not unique, even in our city. I mean, look at all the NFL and NBA players who have been arrested for drugs, domestic violence, gun violations, and even worse. There's even a saying: You can take the kid out of the 'hood, but you can't take the 'hood out of the kid. The difference with Jeremy was that he wasn't a typical 'hood kid. At least, I didn't think he was. Maybe I was dumb all along. That's certainly possible. Either way, it is so, so sad.
DeleteI did not see that coming! I'm sure you mourn what he could have been.
ReplyDeleteJean--I didn't see it coming, either. Not even a little bit. I do mourn for the Old Jeremy, the one that I knew and respected so much.
DeleteOh wow, that is so awful. It really is true that even if you made a positive impact, there are too many other diversions in the world, especially for kids that many people just kinda give up on from the get go.
ReplyDeleteBridget--Jeremy would have had to give up on himself for this tragedy to have happened. His dad was always there for him from what I observed. Of course, that was while he was in high school. Who knows what could have occurred after graduation.
DeleteIt's frustrating: so many idiots blame public schools for so much, as if the kids come in perfect and homogenous and well-fed and from terrific families. And go out into a world of rainbows and happiness. If only.
Dee--I'm sorry that you know how I feel; I really am. There are so many stories like John's and Jeremy's. That this is the case is doubly heartbreaking.
ReplyDeleteWow. I was hoping for a nice outcome; this is very sad. I can see why he and his story touched you.
ReplyDeleteBB Suz--It is very sad. Jeremy had his dad looking out for him, and I know his coaches did, too. He was such a likeable young man, and he seemed to be headed in the right direction all along. I still feel as if it all came out of nowhere, and I can't get over it.
DeleteThat is a wonderful and tragic story. You have to wonder what exactly changes [breaks] in a kid so that he goes from good to bad.
ReplyDeleteAlly--I wonder it more often than you could know. But I suppose it's not just kids, and it's not just an urban story, either. Life can toss things at people that grinds them down and makes them give up at some point. Lots of variables can change a person, make him/her do things that would never have even seemed a remote possibility before. Because I was personally involved with Jeremy at the level I was, and saw him as a good kid, saw his dad being such a positive force, it was beyond shocking to me. It was not the life I saw Jeremy living, and his life now is certainly not the future I imagined for him.
DeleteYou’re right that it’s not just an urban story…I have a similar story in my family, though not quite the same. I had a cousin that I worshiped when we lived in Fairbanks, Alaska, which was a pretty small town at the time. He was a teenager when I was little, and likely saved our lives when we were out on the homestead with no phone and no running water. My mom got terribly sick (reaction to medication) and could not get out of bed. My brother did his best and kept us warm (by carrying coal into the house, small bucket by small bucket, he was six or seven at the time) and fed. A few days went by like this, and my cousin Tony decided that as he had not seen us, which was NOT normal, he would come and check on us. Thank goodness. He brought us into town, got my mom the help she needed, and of course we had a safe warm place to stay.
ReplyDeleteI recently found some letters that my mom had sent my grandma from this time, and in them she talks about how much she loves Tony, what a good kid he is, how he is family and like a son to her. I remember when he left town for some reason, and I cried and cried, fearing I would never see him again.
We lost track of that part of the family when we moved back to California. I know there was a lot of drinking and some drugs in my mom’s generation on that side, and I suppose my mom didn’t want to be around that any longer, I don’t know. Fast forward to 2001, and I found Tony’s mom, my Aunt, on Classmates.com, and reunited with her via email. I asked her about Tony, and she said he was in prison. He and another friend, both on drugs, had gotten a cab to drive them out to the family homestead, the same one where we lived when I was 4 and 5. He intended to rob the driver, and killed him. I don’t remember if he shot him or beat him or what. He went to prison for a long time, he was in prison when I got in touch with my Aunt in 2001. The crime happened in the mid 70s. He finally got parole a few years ago. He turned his life around in prison, and is now living in s VERY small town in the woods of Alaska. We exchanged some letters while he was there, but I haven’t heard from him in a few years.
I am heartbroken by what he did, by how he took that cab driver’s life, how he destroyed the lives of the driver’s family, and how he destroyed his own life in the bargain. I cannot help but hope for the best for him. And I will never understand how any of it happened, though of course I know the facts of it, just not the hard parts.
J--What a story! Your life is worthy of a series of books, as I have often said.
DeleteYou're right; the story of your Tony has many echoes to that of Jeremy's. Your last paragraph states far better exactly how I feel about the circumstances of Jeremy's case.
And I'm sure "the hard parts" are the important parts for both. We simply cannot know what made them lose the best parts of themselves and resort to making horrendous choices. I was such a peripheral figure in Jeremy's life, all things considered. I knew almost nothing about what happened outside of the 40 minutes a day, 5 days a week that I saw him for a year.
I'm glad that you reached out to your cousin and that he did turn his life around. I hope he's still okay.
Oh that must be so strange and sorrowful. Nance, let's hope he is doing something educational in prison . I feel sorry for ANYONE in prison. I always feel a bit of mental illness is to blame. Of course, I do not condone any life taken! Oh Nance. What a story that was
ReplyDeletekathy b--Yes, it is both of those things exactly. It's hard for me to imagine Jeremy being 50 now, let alone him in prison. I do hope he's something of his former self, but in a way, it's sad to think of that, too. I guess I have a hard time thinking of him there, period, and thinking of how he got there, too.
DeleteI don't condone at all what he did, either. There is no excuse, and the Jeremy I knew was obviously not the one who did that.
What a heartbreaking story, especially when you likely hoped you’d perhaps hear about him one day finding a career in counseling or similar, giving guidance to other kids struggling to get ahead. And then the shock and tragedy of just the opposite happening. It’s easy to see how so many of them end up in gangs or selling drugs: why study when you can’t pass the entrance exam, can’t afford it, probably won’t get a great job anyway, and you can make easy money drug-dealing? That's an over-simplification, of course, and who knows what led Jeremy down that path. He must have had a lot of bad breaks between graduation and getting into drugs.
ReplyDeleteAt UT Arlington where I teach, over 80% of our incoming freshmen are on financial aid. Since that doesn’t cover all their expenses, most of them have one or more jobs. And then there are the single moms with a couple of kids, barely keeping their heads above water. I try to cut them some slack whenever I can so they can make it to the finish line and graduate. A lot of them major in social work or criminal justice, especially the Dreamers who still don’t know if they will be able to use their degrees or have to scrub floors or ‘go back to where *their parents* came from.’ *sigh* Our entire higher education system needs to be restructured and affordable for everyone. But it’s complicated, with so many things in society today that are 'broken.'
Ortizzle--Your scenario, while a simplification, is a likely one, and it fits so many kids. And so many of them hang onto dreams of becoming an NFL or NBA star or the next big rapper or producer, making it big, becoming rich quickly, that planning a more realistic path to success never hits their radar. So even the ones who do get to college and get on the field or court, but don't become stars and see that they're not going into the draft start faltering. They often end up looking for quick cash to keep themselves "relevant" and bolster their self-esteem. They can't see themselves coming out of college and going into a boring, regular job. So...
DeleteUT Arlington sounds a lot like our local community college, which also offers four-year degrees in partnership with several Ohio colleges and universities. It's a terrific asset, and it offers high school graduates in the area two scholarships, one 90% paid if the student enters with an 3.7 GPA, the other 70% paid with a 3.4 GPA. Both are for two years and take a 2.5 GPA to maintain.
It's been a constant source of continuing ed for everyone for decades, and it also offers tech, engineering, robotics, and nursing. My siblings and I got associate's degrees there and went on to a four-year college. Classes then and now comprise a wide range of ages. Same thing as what you're describing, except lots and lots of nurses, too.
I agree that college costs are wildly out of control and hugely prohibitive. I honestly do not understand why. Yes, overall costs must go up, but when a year of college is, on average, $10K+ (and that's in OH), something is wrong.
And bless the Dreamers. What a mess and tragedy that is. Why is this so fraught with controversy? They. Stay. Here. Period. They are innocent victims in this. They had no choice. Duh.
You're such a good writer. And that last part of the story was a gut punch. What's hard for me is that so many of these young men don't feel like they have anywhere else to go. And also there is the lure of not working so hard to earn good money. There are so many things systemically wrong that it's hard to figure out how to make a dint in it. But it sounds like your class was just the right kind of welcoming environment that he needed at that time.
ReplyDeleteBug--Thank you. That compliment--about my writing--means a great deal to me.
DeleteReading about Jeremy's arrest was just that--a gut punch. I actually felt sick. It was like all my energy drained out of me.
I think it's so many of the things you mentioned, plus the fact that many don't make realistic goals or reasonable goals for life after high school. Kids are raised on that mantra of "You can do anything, be anything you want to be!" but no one says much about the hard work that it takes for that Anything to come about. Or the lucky breaks. Or the Time Factor. The old saying, "Wishing doesn't make it so" is useful, but too much reality.
Of course, I have no idea what the factors truly are behind Jeremy's turnabout and downward trajectory. The sad thing is that there could be so many.
This is just utterly and totally so sad.
ReplyDeleteVera--It truly is. Sadder still is the fact that Jeremy is just one of many, I'm certain.
DeleteOh - my heart breaks for him (and for all the kids that end up on the wrong path). My cousin had such a very bright future and she threw it away for drugs/alcohol - luckily, she eventually got straight and is healthy and in a happy place - but she will never be the doctor she dreamed of becoming. I know she was lucky...many others aren't.
ReplyDeleteGigi--I'm glad your cousin found her way out of that dark place. It's not easy, and it's always there, waiting for a chance to envelop you again. It's tough to recalibrate your dreams anyway, let alone to have to do it because you just want to survive another day.
DeleteJeremy made the worst decisions he could have. My heart is broken, too.
Oh that poor boy. No matter how he was raised and having you as a teacher he still fell on the hard side of the tracks. It is easier to make money selling drugs that to work full time at minimum wage that can't support you or your family. Bless him and his family who must have been devastated with what happened, there are so many Jeremy's out there. It really is heartbreaking.
ReplyDeleteMeredith--It's so true: There are so many Jeremys out there. Everywhere. I do think of his father, too, who worked so tirelessly to keep him on track and was so attentive and present. I cannot imagine his pain and, as you termed it, devastation.
DeleteI think also about how there are so many factors in a life that we cannot control, as you touched upon. All we can do is try to make things better as a whole, for as many as we can, and be kind to individuals whenever we can.
The family you are born into, the color of your skin, where you ae born, your financial stability or instability, who you love, how your brain learns, exposure to drugs and alcohol or abuse, well it all matters. I see so many children born addicted to drugs and the impact it has on their development early on, but it continues to impact them throughout their lives even though I don't see them all grown up. That poor boys father. Trying so hard to keep him in check, being such a presence in his life. But young men as we know make very bad choices because they don't see the big picture of their actions, that frontal lobe is far from developed until far into their 20's. It is a shame that those early bad decisions affect the outcome of the rest of their lives. Never doubt you had an impact, it might not be visible to you but you instilled love and compassion into kids that might not have ever had that anywhere else in their lives. Plus you respected them, how often did they ever feel respected or even heard?
ReplyDeleteMeredith--Your experience working with children gives you a terrific amount of perspective and knowledge. It's so true that exposure in the womb/development to toxins like drugs, alcohol, and the lack of proper nutrition and prenatal care gives kids an unfair penalty at the very start; the minute they take their first breath, they are already at a disadvantage, and some disadvantages are nearly impossible to overcome if the environment they live in isn't aware and compensating for them.
DeleteI do know that I tried hard to foster an atmosphere of warmth and mutual respect. I thank you for your encouragement and kind words. It's so hard--even so many years now--to know that we lost one that had so much potential. I never, ever saw it coming.
That is a shame Jeremy lost his way with wrong choices. We don't always know what becomes of those we've taught or provided rehabilitation services -- perhaps, sometimes it's just as well.
ReplyDeleteJoared--It's a sadness, truly. You may be right; his is certainly not the only story like this among my former students, just one that I know of. This makes it perhaps even more poignant.
Delete